This site contains commercial content

Which Bookmaker is the Best For American Sports Betting?

Best Bookmaker For American Sports Betting

American sports have become increasingly popular on this side of the water over a number of years. As such, bookmakers have also jumped on board, offering a range of odds and markets on basketball, baseball, American Football, and ice hockey.

For our best bookmaker for American sports betting review, we’ve concentrated on three of the biggest sports leagues on the State – the best bookmaker for NFL, best bookmaker for NBA and best bookmaker for NHL.

If you’re new to betting on American sports, and these competitions, in particular, it can be difficult to ascertain which bookmaker offers the best all-round experience. Where are the best odds? Who offers the biggest range of markets? Our aim with this research was to answer those questions, looking at each league specifically, along with an overall assessment to decide on the best bookmaker for American sports betting.

We conducted our research during the period of 13/11/19 and 18/11/19. Our results are purely based on this timeframe.

To help us come to an educated conclusion on who is the best bookmaker for American sports betting, we analyzed the following games:

  • NFL: New England Patriots vs Philadelphia Eagles
  • NFL: Chicago Bears vs Los Angeles Rams
  • NBA: Chicago Bulls vs Milwaukee Bucks
  • NBA: New York Knicks vs Dallas Mavericks
  • NBA: Los Angeles Clippers vs New Orleans Pelicans
  • NHL: Arizona Coyotes vs Minnesota Wild
  • NHL: Winnipeg Jets vs Florida Panthers
  • NHL: New York Rangers vs Tampa Bay Lightning

We tested a number of criteria in order to give a thorough review and insight into the best bookmaker for American sports betting. We looked at odds for Moneyline, Totals and Spread, to find who has the lowest commission rates. We will look at our overall findings shortly, followed by a discussion about the best bookmaker for each individual sport.

The operators tested for our research are listed here.

bet365 Betfair Betway Matchbook
Genting Bet Ladbrokes Winner Sports Coral Paddy Power
Betfred Betsafe BetVictor Boylesports Marathonbet
NetBet Stan James 888sport William Hill Leo Vegas
Energybet skybet white PETAR ALT Sportingbet
Gentingbet Logo 10Bet Logo

Overall Top Bookmakers For American Sports

Let’s head straight to our top five bookmakers for betting on American sports. After collating and analyzing all of the data we had gathered, we found that William Hill offers the best all-round betting experience.

Best Bookmaker For American Sports Betting

Best Bookmaker For American Sports Betting

Our top five looks like this.

  • William Hill
  • Betfair
  • Unibet
  • Mr Green
  • Matchbook

We were particularly impressed with what William Hill offers for NHL betting. This operator was consistently amongst the top bookmakers for competitive odds, namely Moneyline, Totals and Spread, on each game we tested.

The same can also be said for their results on NFL and NBA betting. We found a good range of markets available at William Hill for each game we researched, which means bettors have a good range from which to choose from.

In second place comes Betfair. Betfair offers the highest number of markets, in general, across all sports tested. After analyzing results on each individual sport, we found that Betfair come top for NFL, second for NBA betting and third for NHL.

The third is Unibet. This may come as a surprise to some, but those of you who read our bookmaker comparisons regularly will know that Unibet performs well in almost every aspect of sports betting we research. For our best bookmaker for American sports betting, Unibet impressed with the range of markets offered and the average number of markets available on each game. Unibet also came out on top as the best bookmaker for NBA betting. More of this shortly.

In fourth place is Mr. Green. Relatively new to the online sports betting scene, Mr. Green offers a good range of odds and markets across all games tested, in particular with NBA and NHL betting.

Matchbook rounds up our top five list for best bookmakers for American sports betting. We found that Matchbook offered the best odds on almost every game and the market we tested, showing that if you’re solely focused on getting the best odds possible, this betting exchange is worth considering.

Let’s now look at the individual sports we researched, starting with the best bookmaker for NFL betting.

Best Bookmaker For NFL

We’re going to show you each aspect of our research to find the best bookmaker for NFL betting shortly. First, let’s take a general overview. Our top-performing bookmakers for NFL betting, in general, were as follows.

  1. Betfair
  2. Betsafe
  3. William Hill
  4. Matchbook
  5. Unibet
  6. UPaddy Power

The results of our analysis for the NFL games between New England Patriots and Philadelphia Eagles, along with Chicago Bears vs LA Rams, indicated those bookmakers who offer the lowest commission.

Best NFL Markets

  1. Paddy Power
  2. Betfair
  3. bet365

Best NFL Odds: Moneyline

  1. Matchbook – 0.65%
  2. William Hill – 3.03%
  3. Unibet – 3.27%

Best NFL Odds: Total

  1. Matchbook – 1.62%
  2. Marathonbet – 2.56%
  3. Betsafe – 3.50%

Best NFL Odds: Spread

  1. Matchbook – 0.25%
  2. Marathonbet – 2.58%
  3. Netbet – 3.63%

Best Bookmaker For NBA

Now onto the best bookmaker for NBA betting. As we touched upon earlier, Unibet came out on top of this list, offering an excellent, all-round betting experience. Who’s joined them in our quest to find the best bookmaker for NBA betting? Let’s take a look.

  1. Unibet
  2. Betfair
  3. Mr Green
  4. William Hill
  5. 888sport
  6. Matchbook
  7. LeoVegas

As we did earlier, let’s separate each aspect of our research to find the best bookmakers for each criteria. Remember, the results for odds include the rate of commission.

Best NBA Markets

  1. Betfair
  2. Paddy Power
  3. bet365

Best NBA Odds: Moneyline

  1. Matchbook – 1.55%
  2. Marathonbet – 2.56%
  3. Ladbrokes – 3.61%

Best NBA Odds: Totals

  1. Matchbook – 1.80%
  2. Premier Punt – 4.17%
  3. Energy Bet – 4.41%

Best NBA Odds: Spread

  1. Matchbook – 0.92%
  2. Premier Punt – 3.92%
  3. Sportingbet – 4.12%

Best Bookmaker For NHL

Lastly, let’s look at who performed well in our best bookmaker for NHL betting research. The following bookmakers impressed us with their overall NHL betting facilities, with William Hill leading the way.

  1. William Hill
  2. Mr Green
  3. Betfair
  4. Premier Punt
  5. Matchbook
  6. Unibet
  7. 888sport

Let’s look at the individual stats for our best bookmaker for NHL betting review.

Best NHL Markets

  1. Mr Green
  2. 888sport
  3. Unibet
  4. LeoVegas
  5. Betfair

Best NHL Odds: Moneyline

  1. Matchbook – 0.67%
  2. William Hill – 3.47%
  3. bet365 – 4.11%

Best NHL Odds: Total

  1. Matchbook – 1.16%
  2. Premier Punt – 4.16%
  3. William Hill – 4.36%

Odds: Spread

  1. Matchbook – 1.37%
  2. William Hill – 3.50%
  3. Marathonbet – 3.90%

Best Bookmaker For American Sports Betting: Conclusion

As part of our best bookmaker for the American sports betting review, we analyzed overall results as well as selected markets for each individual sport. If you’re looking to bet on different American sports, our top five list at the top of the page should be considered, with William Hill taking the number one place.
If you’re looking to specialize in betting on a particular sport, then look at our individual results for the best bookmaker for NFL betting, best bookmaker for NBA betting and best bookmaker for NHL betting.

It’s also important to consider what you’re actually looking for in a bookmaker. Focusing on the best odds possible? Or looking for an operator who can offer a more well-rounded experience?

A handful of the operators tested also offer live streaming on selected American sports events. Bet365 is the most prolific, though others, including Mr. Green, can offer live streaming on major events, such as the playoffs.

Every bookmaker tested can, of course, improve on their offerings. It’s important to remind you that these results are only valid for the time period stated above and for the particular games we assessed.